Is there a better way?
In baseball recruiting, “old school” and “new school” refer to two different approaches to evaluating and selecting players.
Old school recruiting tends to rely more on traditional scouting methods, such as observing a player’s physical tools (e.g., speed, arm strength, hitting ability) and overall “intangibles” (e.g., work ethic, attitude, mental toughness). Scouts and coaches might also rely on personal connections and word-of-mouth recommendations from trusted sources.
New school recruiting, on the other hand, often involves more advanced statistical analysis and data-driven methods. This might include using metrics like exit velocity, spin rate, and launch angle to evaluate a player’s performance, or using machine learning algorithms to identify patterns and predict future success.
Both approaches have their advantages and drawbacks, and many teams use a combination of both. Old school recruiting can be valuable for identifying players who might be overlooked by more data-driven methods, while new school recruiting can help teams identify hidden gems and avoid costly mistakes.
Ultimately, the most successful recruiting strategies will depend on a team’s specific needs and resources, as well as the broader trends and developments in the sport of baseball.
The argument for “New School” Recruiting
Technology has revolutionized baseball recruiting, providing teams and scouts with new tools and methods to evaluate and select players. Here are some of the benefits of technology in baseball recruiting:
Improved scouting accuracy: Technology has enabled scouts and coaches to track and analyze a vast amount of data, including video footage, statistical analysis, and biometric data. This has allowed them to identify patterns and trends that might have gone unnoticed before, leading to more accurate evaluations of players’ skills and potential.
Faster and more efficient scouting: With the use of technology, scouts can now review video footage of players from anywhere in the world without having to travel to see them in person. This has made the scouting process faster and more efficient, allowing teams to evaluate more players in less time.
Better injury prevention: Technology has enabled teams to monitor players’ health and fitness levels more closely, using wearable sensors and other devices to track their movements, heart rate, and other biometric data. This has allowed teams to identify potential injury risks and adjust training regimens accordingly, helping to prevent injuries and extend players’ careers.
Increased fan engagement: Technology has also enhanced the fan experience, with features like instant replays, real-time statistical updates, and interactive fan engagement tools. This has helped to build stronger connections between fans and teams, leading to increased loyalty and revenue.
Overall, technology has transformed the way that baseball teams recruit and develop players, leading to more accurate evaluations, faster scouting, better injury prevention, and increased fan engagement.
The argument for “Old School” Recruiting
While new school baseball recruiting methods have gained popularity in recent years, there are still benefits to using old school methods to evaluate and select players. Here are some of the benefits of old school baseball recruiting:
Personal connections: Old school recruiting often relies on personal connections and relationships built between scouts, coaches, and players. This can lead to a deeper understanding of a player’s character, work ethic, and potential, and can help teams identify hidden gems who might not be on the radar of other teams.
Traditional scouting methods: Old school recruiting often involves in-person scouting and observation of players, which can provide a more complete picture of a player’s skills and potential. This can include evaluating a player’s body language, demeanor, and overall approach to the game, which may not be captured by data-driven methods.
Intangible factors: Old school recruiting often places greater emphasis on a player’s intangible qualities, such as leadership, mental toughness, and grit. These qualities can be difficult to quantify with data-driven methods, but can be crucial in determining a player’s success at the next level.
Regional expertise: Old school recruiting often involves scouts with deep knowledge of specific regions or areas, allowing them to identify talent that might be overlooked by more general scouting methods. This can be especially valuable in areas where there is a rich tradition of baseball, but where resources and exposure might be limited.
A Balanced approach is best
Overall, there are still benefits to old school baseball recruiting methods, including personal connections, traditional scouting methods, intangible factors, and regional expertise. While data-driven methods have become increasingly important in baseball recruiting, a balanced approach that incorporates both old school and new school methods can lead to the most accurate evaluations of players’ skills and potential.
At the Baseball Bluebook, we believe in a balanced approach. There is no “secret” in finding your next playing opportunity. Our app offers a wholistic approach to your baseball journey. No matter what league, travel team or organization you participate in, we provide a platform to highlight your journey. Search our comprehensive directory, post your latest highlight video and add your latest stats. Bringing a balance to recruiting requires leveraging the new and the old. The Baseball Bluebook, helping the baseball community find their next opportunity since 1909.
Download today and become part of the fastest growing baseball community in the industry.
